In May 2003, Mildred Crowley (Crowley) crossed the threshold for her first day as an office manager at a Lemont, Illinois construction company (the Company). For over six years, Crowley worked for the Company and was considered a reliable friend and employee. Crowley had access to bank accounts, financial records, and checks.
In July 2009, Crowley obtained a credit card in her name from a bank the Company used for credit card services (Bank B). She obtained the credit card without permission from the Company.
Over the next 11 years, Crowley used the secret credit card to fund her lifestyle without the Company knowing. She had a private 10-acre horse farm and kept show horses. She purchased countless meals, funded travel, and enjoyed a life of luxury obtained by fraudulent means. In addition to the credit card, Crowley wrote checks to herself totaling $100,000. In total, Crowley embezzled more than $2.3 million from the Company.
Crowley had Bank B send the credit card bills directly to her. Several times a month, she made payments from the Company’s main bank account (Bank A). Crowley typically wrote checks and delivered them directly to Bank B herself. On one occasion, she initiated an electronic payment for the credit card bill. After paying Bank B, Crowley altered the Company’s financial records to reflect that payments went to legitimate vendors.
In 2018, the Company’s performance suffered and it posted a net loss of $77,000. When asked about the loss and what drove it, Crowley indicated the loss was due to increased wages to labor unions and equipment purchases. In reality, she embezzled far more than $77,000 that year.
In 2020, another employee discovered the fraud and promptly contacted the FBI. On December 29, 2020, a criminal information was filed against Crowley for her involvement in the fraud. She self-surrendered shortly after and was released on a $4,500 bond.
Crowley originally pleaded not guilty to one count of wire fraud. She later changed her plea to guilty and was sentenced to 37 months in prison, two years of supervised release, and restitution of about $2.27 million. Among the many requirements of supervised release, she could not:
work at a job with access to business finances
work at a job with access to personally identifiable information of others
obtain additional credit
Crowley also had to provide financial information to the probation officer on request.
Her legal team requested a reduced sentence due to her age (mid-70s) and physical ailments. The request was denied.
Crowley surrendered to the Bureau of Prisons in January 2024, with a scheduled release date of June 20, 2026. She was released from prison on November 7, 2025, after about 22 months.
It’s difficult to run a small business without complete trust in your staff, especially someone who has been with the business for many years. However, trust works best with verification. While verifying information is not guaranteed to stop embezzlement before it starts, there are certain steps which can mitigate the risk or catch fraud sooner.
Know every account in your name and have statements come to you. Each year, ask your banks for a list of all accounts and cards tied to your business. That one request would have revealed Crowley’s hidden card. Also have bank and credit card statements sent directly to you. Crowley rerouted the bills to herself, and nobody noticed.
Look beyond the ledger. The accounting records reflected a vendor name, while the checks went to Bank B. Spot-check cleared checks against the books. Keep the person writing the checks from also recording and reconciling them. Requiring dual approval for ACH and wire transfers, and the owner’s signature on checks, let you see every payment and who receives it.
Verify explanations. Crowley blamed the 2018 loss on union wages and equipment purchases, and no one checked. When something looks off, confirm the answer against payroll costs, invoices, or asset records.
Crowley was trusted for 17 years, while the fraud ran for 11 of those years. Trust your people but verify anyway. Verification isn’t distrust. It’s the cost of trust and it’s much cheaper than $2.3 million.